Top 7 Restaurants in Venice, FL Perfect for New Residents

Chad Coatney • March 26, 2025

Moving to a new city is always an adventure, and few things help you feel at home faster than exploring the local dining scene. If you’ve recently relocated to Venice, FL, congratulations—you’ve landed in a charming coastal town filled with beautiful beaches, vibrant art galleries, and, most importantly, a thriving food scene. From fresh seafood served with waterfront views to cozy Italian gems that feel like a home-cooked meal, Venice offers a delicious variety of dining experiences waiting to be discovered.

For new residents, these culinary hotspots provide an incredible way to immerse yourself in the community, connect with neighbors, and indulge in unforgettable meals. As you settle into your new home, let Master Movers handle all the heavy lifting, so you can focus on savoring everything Venice has to offer.

Ready to dive into the local flavor? Here are the Top 7 Restaurants in Venice, FL, perfect for new residents exploring their new hometown.


1. Crow’s Nest Marina & Restaurant

Famous For: Waterfront dining and fresh Gulf seafood

When it comes to iconic Venice eats, Crow’s Nest Marina & Restaurant is hard to beat. Perched on the Intracoastal Waterway, this beloved spot pairs stunning waterfront views with a menu that celebrates local seafood.

What Makes It Special:

This historic, family-owned restaurant has been a favorite since 1976, offering both an upstairs fine dining atmosphere and a relaxed tavern downstairs.

  • Signature Dishes: The Grouper Key Largo (grouper prepared with key lime butter) is a must-try, as are their Crab Cakes, brimming with fresh lump crab meat.
  • Dietary Options: Seafood lovers will find plenty of gluten-free and low-carb dishes.

Who You'll See: Families enjoying a weekend meal, local boating enthusiasts docking for lunch, and seafood lovers soaking up the sunset views.

2. Cassariano Italian Eatery

Famous For: Authentic Italian flavors in a modern setting

Located in the heart of downtown Venice, Cassariano Italian Eatery brings a fresh, contemporary twist to traditional Italian fare. It’s a perfect spot for date nights, celebratory dinners, or just treating yourself to quality cuisine.

What Makes It Special:

Founded by two Italian culinary masters, Cassariano uses high-quality ingredients and recipes inspired by their heritage. Everything is served in a cozy yet upscale dining room.

  • Signature Dishes: Try the Fiocchi Gorgonzola, ravioli stuffed with pear and gorgonzola drizzled with a creamy sauce—you won’t regret it. The Osso Buco is another standout for fans of tender, slow-cooked veal.
  • Dietary Options: Gluten-free pasta options available.

Who You'll See: Foodies, couples celebrating milestones, and professionals gathering for sophisticated lunches.


3. Sharky’s on the Pier

Famous For: Waterfront views and laid-back beach vibes

No trip to Venice is complete without dining at Sharky’s on the Pier, a casual yet iconic seafood restaurant located right on the beach. It’s one of the most recommended spots for fresh fish, tropical cocktails, and Instagram-worthy views.

What Makes It Special:

Sharky’s sits directly next to the Venice Fishing Pier, giving diners a front-row seat to gorgeous sunsets over the Gulf of Mexico. The relaxed, beachy atmosphere is ideal for families and tourists alike.

  • Signature Dishes: The Baja Grouper Tacos are a fan favorite, while the Coconut Shrimp delivers a sweet crunch in every bite. Pair your meal with their famous Rumrunner cocktail.
  • Dietary Options: Fresh salads and lighter fare for healthy eaters.

Who You'll See: Tourists exploring the beach, families on vacation, and locals unwinding after a long day.


4. Fins at Sharky’s

Famous For: Upscale dining with unbeatable Gulf views

An extension of Sharky’s but with a more refined touch, Fins at Sharky’s offers creative coastal cuisine in an upscale yet approachable atmosphere.

What Makes It Special:

With floor-to-ceiling windows overlooking the water, Fins specializes in high-quality steaks and seafood, served with artistic presentation. Its full raw bar is also an impressive addition to its menu.

  • Signature Dishes: Don’t miss their Filet Oscar, topped with lump crab, asparagus, and bearnaise sauce. The Sashimi Tuna Tostada is another appetizer that steals the show.
  • Dietary Options: Plenty of fresh and healthy seafood options.

Who You'll See: Couples on date nights, groups celebrating special occasions, and seafood lovers craving premium fare.


5. Darrell’s Restaurant

Famous For: Classic Southern BBQ with a Florida twist

Looking for comfort food while settling into Venice? Darrell’s Restaurant delivers smoky, homestyle barbecue dishes crafted with heart and soul.

What Makes It Special:

This locally owned gem is the go-to spot for BBQ lovers in Venice. With laid-back vibes and generous portions, Darrell’s is a welcoming place where you can relax and indulge.

  • Signature Dishes: Brisket that melts in your mouth, ribs slathered in the perfect sauce, and sides like cornbread and creamy mac & cheese.
  • Dietary Options: Keto and low-carb options are available for meat lovers looking to stay on track.

Who You'll See: Families, BBQ enthusiasts, and longtime locals who claim it’s the best barbecue in town.


6. Made in Italy

Famous For: Traditional Italian cuisine paired with a lively bar scene

For an authentic slice of Italy, Made in Italy is a top choice for Venice residents. With a bustling atmosphere and extensive drink menu, this downtown favorite feels like a trip to Rome or Milan without leaving Florida.

What Makes It Special:

Made in Italy proudly uses fresh, imported ingredients to recreate traditional recipes like Nonna used to make. Their wood-fired pizzas are especially popular.

  • Signature Dishes: Try their Truffle Pizza or Handmade Gnocchi with Gorgonzola Sauce. The Espresso Martini is the perfect way to end your meal.
  • Dietary Options: Vegetarian-friendly pasta dishes and salads available.

Who You'll See: Groups of friends enjoying happy hour, couples savoring Italian classics, and anyone craving authentic pizza.


7. Blu’ Island Bistro

Famous For: Creative breakfast and brunch

If breakfast is your favorite meal of the day, you’ll feel right at home at Blu’ Island Bistro. This cheerful spot offers all-day breakfast along with creative lunch and bistro options made with locally sourced ingredients.

What Makes It Special:

Blu’ Island Bistro prides itself on being a chef-driven restaurant, meaning every dish is crafted with care by people passionate about food.

  • Signature Dishes: The Blu’ Crab & Shrimp Benedict is a standout favorite, while the Southern Grit Surprise adds a twist to traditional Southern staples.
  • Dietary Options: Gluten-free pancake and vegetarian options are available.

Who You'll See: Morning enthusiasts, brunch-loving foodies, and locals catching up over breakfast.

Settle In, Savor the Flavor

Venice, FL, truly offers a diverse dining scene that can cater to any craving, from laid-back beach bars to upscale fine dining. If you’ve just moved here, spending time exploring these incredible restaurants is not only enjoyable—it’s also a great way to connect with the heart and soul of your new community.

Relocating to a new city doesn’t have to be a stressful process. With Master Movers on your side, your transition to life in Venice can be smooth, efficient, and even enjoyable. While Master Movers takes care of all the unpacking and logistics, you’ll be free to dive into the vibrant dining scene that makes Venice such a special place to call home.

Ready to start your new life in beautiful Venice, FL? Let the experts at Master Movers handle the move, so you can settle into your new neighborhood and spend your time enjoying the local flavors—even before the boxes are unpacked! Bon appétit!

Our Latest Blog

Discover the Natural Splendors: Exploring the Top 7 Parks in Myakka City, Florida

By Chad Coatney • May 16, 2025
Nestled in the heart of Florida, Myakka City is a gem that boasts an array of green spaces, offering both residents and visitors alike a myriad of opportunities to connect with nature and indulge in recreational activities. Known for its lush landscapes and vibrant wildlife, the city serves as a perfect backdrop for those looking to escape the hustle and bustle of urban life. Parks play a crucial role in enhancing our quality of life, not only by providing spaces for exercise and relaxation but also by fostering community connections and promoting environmental stewardship. In Myakka City, Florida parks are more than just green spaces; they are places where memories are made, where families gather, and where nature’s wonders are preserved for future generations. Myakka River State Park - A Treasure Trove of Natural Beauty Myakka River State Park stands as one of the largest and oldest parks in Florida and is a cornerstone of natural beauty in Myakka City. Spread across 58 square miles, this park teems with diverse ecosystems, lush foliage, and abundant wildlife, including deer, alligators, and a myriad of bird species. Activities: Hiking and Biking: Explore over 39 miles of trails tailored for varying levels of adventure seekers. Bird Watching: The park’s birdwalk offers a prime viewing spot for avian enthusiasts. Canoeing and Kayaking: Glide along the scenic Myakka River and enjoy up-close encounters with the park’s aquatic life. Special Attractions: The Canopy Walkway: Experience breathtaking views from above the treetops on this suspension bridge and tower. Wildlife Observation: Designated viewing platforms provide vantage points to safely observe and photograph wildlife in their natural habitats.

Discover Culinary Delights: Top 7 Must-Visit Restaurants in Englewood, FL

By Chad Coatney • May 16, 2025
Englewood, Florida, with its serene beaches and quaint disposition, isn't just a haven for beach-goers and sun seekers— it's also a burgeoning hotspot for culinary explorers. From fresh seafood pulled directly from the Gulf to cozy cafes offering homemade delights, the dining scene in Englewood, Florida encapsulates both the spirit and flavor of this charming town. In this guide, we dive into the top 7 restaurants that define Englewood's vibrant food culture, offering everything from casual bites to gourmet meals. Why Explore Englewood’s Dining Scene? Englewood, located on Florida's Gulf Coast, offers not just picturesque landscapes and a relaxing ambiance but also a rich tapestry of culinary delights. This small town, with its close-knit community, pools a variety of cuisines that reflect its diverse population and the natural bounty of its surroundings. Key reasons to dive into Englewood's food scene include: Local Flavor: Restaurants here serve up dishes that highlight locally-sourced ingredients, offering genuine tastes of the region's culinary richness. Diversity: From traditional American eateries to exotic international cuisine, there's a taste for every palate. Ambiance: Many Englewood restaurants feature settings that allow diners to bask in the town's natural beauty, be it on waterfront decks or quaint, art-filled interiors. How We Chose the Best Restaurants in Englewood Selecting the top eateries in a place as diverse as Englewood was no small feat. To ensure a mix of tastes and experiences, we used a comprehensive approach, choosing establishments that excel in several key areas. Criteria for Selection: Menu Variety: We looked for restaurants offering unique menu options that cater to a range of dietary preferences and culinary tastes. Customer Reviews: Feedback from diners regarding their experiences—covering food quality, service, and overall satisfaction—played a crucial role. Service Quality: Fast, friendly, and efficient service weighed heavily in our consideration. Ambiance: The environment of the restaurant is just as important as the food. We selected places that offer a pleasing atmosphere, whether cozy or sophisticated. Unique Features: Restaurants that offered something beyond the ordinary, like live music, art displays, or exceptional views, were also favored. 

Inside Bird Key: Neighborhoods Explained

By Chad Coatney • May 15, 2025
Nestled neatly between Sarasota and St. Armands, Bird Key, Florida , stands as a beacon of coastal charm and serene living. This prestigious community is not just a place to live; it's a lifestyle marked by luxury, privacy, and closeness to the splashing waves of the Gulf of Mexico. Whether you're contemplating a move or simply exploring the potentials of Florida's west coast, Bird Key offers a glimpse into a life of tranquil opulence. The History and Development of Bird Key Bird Key has undergone significant transformations to become the luxurious enclave it is today. Originally a modestly sized landmass, Bird Key was expanded considerably in the 1950s and 1960s through ambitious land reclamation projects spearheaded by John Ringling North, a relative of the famed circus entrepreneur, John Ringling. This initiative transformed Bird Key from a simple, underdeveloped island into a sprawling residential area ripe for high-end living. Mapping Out Bird Key: Key Districts and Neighborhoods Bird Key, though relatively small in area, is meticulously organized into distinct districts that each offer unique living experiences. The island can be generally divided into waterfront, garden, and canal-front zones, each with its own appeal. Waterfront Properties: These homes boast direct access to Sarasota Bay, offering expansive views and private docks. Perfect for boating enthusiasts or those who simply cherish the open water views. Garden Homes: Located in the heart of Bird Key, these properties are surrounded by lush landscaping and provide a more secluded, quiet residential living environment. Canal-Front Homes: Situated along the numerous canals that traverse Bird Key, these homes have private boat slips and direct access to the bay, combining convenience with beautiful waterway views. Prominent Neighborhoods and What They Offer Each neighborhood within Bird Key is designed to maximize comfort and aesthetic pleasure, but they also each have particular characteristics worth noting: North Bird Key: Known for its larger lots and newer, contemporary home designs. It’s popular among families looking for space and modernity. Central Bird Key: Features a mix of older, elegant homes that encapsulate the original charm of the island with well-preserved mid-century designs. South Bird Key: Offers closer proximity to St. Armand's Circle and tends to have more active community engagement and slightly denser housing.